Pontryagin dual group inherits local compactness
I'm studying Pontryagin duality, and I read that the dual of a locally compact group $G$ is still locally compact.
EDIT: I got that this is indeed true.
Do you know how to prove it?
It seems to me that one have to prove that the closure of $V(K, varepsilon) ={f: f(K) subset (-varepsilon, varepsilon) } $ is compact for some $K, varepsilon$. This would be a compact neighborhood of the constant character.
Infact, suppose that there a is a compact neighborhood $C$ of the constant character. Then there is some element of the basis $V(K, varepsilon)subset C $. Its closure would be closed in a compact, thus compact.
But I can't succed in showing the fact I mentioned. Thank you for the help, Andrea
uniform-convergence topological-groups
add a comment |
I'm studying Pontryagin duality, and I read that the dual of a locally compact group $G$ is still locally compact.
EDIT: I got that this is indeed true.
Do you know how to prove it?
It seems to me that one have to prove that the closure of $V(K, varepsilon) ={f: f(K) subset (-varepsilon, varepsilon) } $ is compact for some $K, varepsilon$. This would be a compact neighborhood of the constant character.
Infact, suppose that there a is a compact neighborhood $C$ of the constant character. Then there is some element of the basis $V(K, varepsilon)subset C $. Its closure would be closed in a compact, thus compact.
But I can't succed in showing the fact I mentioned. Thank you for the help, Andrea
uniform-convergence topological-groups
add a comment |
I'm studying Pontryagin duality, and I read that the dual of a locally compact group $G$ is still locally compact.
EDIT: I got that this is indeed true.
Do you know how to prove it?
It seems to me that one have to prove that the closure of $V(K, varepsilon) ={f: f(K) subset (-varepsilon, varepsilon) } $ is compact for some $K, varepsilon$. This would be a compact neighborhood of the constant character.
Infact, suppose that there a is a compact neighborhood $C$ of the constant character. Then there is some element of the basis $V(K, varepsilon)subset C $. Its closure would be closed in a compact, thus compact.
But I can't succed in showing the fact I mentioned. Thank you for the help, Andrea
uniform-convergence topological-groups
I'm studying Pontryagin duality, and I read that the dual of a locally compact group $G$ is still locally compact.
EDIT: I got that this is indeed true.
Do you know how to prove it?
It seems to me that one have to prove that the closure of $V(K, varepsilon) ={f: f(K) subset (-varepsilon, varepsilon) } $ is compact for some $K, varepsilon$. This would be a compact neighborhood of the constant character.
Infact, suppose that there a is a compact neighborhood $C$ of the constant character. Then there is some element of the basis $V(K, varepsilon)subset C $. Its closure would be closed in a compact, thus compact.
But I can't succed in showing the fact I mentioned. Thank you for the help, Andrea
uniform-convergence topological-groups
uniform-convergence topological-groups
edited Jan 26 '18 at 21:50
Andrea Marino
asked Jan 26 '18 at 19:21
Andrea MarinoAndrea Marino
18926
18926
add a comment |
add a comment |
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
This is a little silly, since there must be a proof out there in books.
The local compactness of $hat G$ is going to come from equicontinuity.
Say $K$ is a compact neighborhood of the identity in $G$, $0<alpha<1$, and $E$ is the set of all $chiinhat G$ such that $|1-chi|<alpha$ on $K$. Then $E$ is equicontinuous at the origin: Given $epsilon>0$, there exists $n$ such that if $zinBbb T$ and $epsilonle|1-z|<alpha$ then $|1-z^j|>alpha$ for at least one integer $j$ with $1le jle n$ (the fact that $alpha<1$ can't be omitted there.)
Edit: When I wrote this I was taking that last sentence as clear.. In answer to a comment, here's a formal proof. Note first that $|1-e^{is}|$ is a strictly increasing function of $s$, for $sin[0,pi]$. Now wlog $z$ has positive imaginary part. Hence there exists $tin (0,pi/2]$ with $z=e^{it}$. So $tge|1-e^{it}|>epsilon$. Choose $thetain(0,pi)$ with $|1-e^{itheta}|=alpha$. Since $t>epsilon$ there exists $j$ with $1le jle theta/epsilon+1<pi/(2epsilon)+1$ such that $(j-1)tle theta<jt$.
Hence $jt=(j-1)t+tle theta+pi/2lepi$. Since $theta<jtlepi$ the mmontonicity mentioned above shows that $|1-z^j|>|1-e^{itheta}|=alpha$.
Now choose a neighborhood of the origin $U$ such that $U+U+Udots +Usubset K$. Then if $chiin E$ the fact that $chi$ is multiplicative shows that $|1-chi|<epsilon$ on $U$.
So $E$ is equicontinuous at the origin, and hence uniformly equicontinuous at every point. Now a suitable version of Arzela-Ascoli(???) must show that $E$ is precompact in the compact-open topology.
Surely that's all there is to it.
Edit: Yes, that's all there is to it.
Details: Say a modulus of continuity on $G$ is a function $omega:(0,infty)tomathcal P(G)$ such that (i) $omega(epsilon)$ is a neighborhood of the identity for every $epsilon>0$ and $(ii)$ $-omega(epsilon)=omega(epsilon)$. (Note: (ii) is just for convenience; it's no real restriction, since if $omega$ satisfies (i) and $omega'(epsilon)=omega(epsilon)cap(-omega(epsilon))$ then $omega'$ satisfies (i) and (ii).)
Let $hat G_omega$ be the set of $chiinhat G$ such that $x-yinomega(epsilon)$ implies $|chi(x)-chi(y)|leepsilon$.
We're trying to show that $E$ is precompact. Above we've shown that there is a modulus of continuity $omega$ such that if $chiin E$ and $xinomega(epsilon)$ then $|1-chi(x)|<epsilon$. It follows that $chiinhat G_omega$: If $x-yinomega(epsilon)$ then $$|chi(x)-chi(y)|=|chi(x)(1-chi(y-x)|=|1-chi(y-x)|<epsilon.$$
So $Esubsethat G_omega$, and hence we need only show this:
If $omega$ is a modulus of continuity on $G$ then $hat G_omega$ is compact (in the compact-open topology).
This is just Arzela-Ascoli. I don't recall seeing a version that applies directly, so we just prove it.
The proof is clearest in terms of nets. We need to show that every net has a convergent subnet. In a word, Tychonoff gies pointwise convergence and then equicontinuity shows that pointwise convegence implies uniform convergence on compact sets.
Say $(chi_alpha)$ is a net in $hat G_omega$. Regarding $hat G_omega$ as a subset of the product space $Bbb T^G$, Tychonoff shows that there is a pointwise convergent subnet. So we need only show this:
If $omega $ is a modulus of continuity on $G$ and $(chi_alpha)$ is a net in $hat G_omega$ such that $chi_alpha(x)tochi(x)$ for every $xin G$ then $chiin hat G_omega$ and $chi_alphatochi$ uniformly on compact sets.
Proof: The pointwise convergence makes it clear that $chiinhat G_omega$. Suppose $Ksubset G$ is compact and $epsilon>0$. Let $U=omega(epsilon)$ and choose $x_1,dots,x_nin K$ with $$Ksubsetbigcup_{j=1}^n(x_j+U).$$
Now there exists $beta$ such that if $alpha>beta$ then $$|chi_alpha(x_j)-chi(x_j)|<epsilonquad(j=1,2,dots,n).$$
Suppose $alpha>beta$ and $xin K$. Choose $j$ so $xin x_j+U$. Then
$$|chi_alpha(x)-chi(x)|le|chi_alpha(x)-chi_alpha(x_j)|+|chi_alpha(x_j)-chi(x_j)|+|chi(x_j)-chi(x)|<3epsilon.$$
Ok, so I will change my question into a positive one.
– Andrea Marino
Jan 26 '18 at 19:57
@AndreaMarino Wake up - the proof you ordered is ready...
– David C. Ullrich
Jan 28 '18 at 16:12
For whoever asked that deleted question: Say $z=e^{it}$, $0<t<pi/2$. Choose $thetain(0,pi/2)$ with $|1-e^{itheta}|=alpha$. Let $j$ be the smallest positive integer with $jt>theta$.
– David C. Ullrich
Jan 3 at 16:18
@DavidC.Ullrich: That was probably me, and I was asking whether the statement "Given $epsilon>0$, there exists $n$ such that if [...]" is obvious. How do you construct this $n$ which must be independent of all $z$?
– Alex M.
Jan 3 at 22:12
@AlexM. I gave an outline in my last comment. II should have said wlog $z$ has positive imaginary part. More details: Knowing that $|1-z|>epsilon$ shows that $t>epsilon$. Since $theta<pi/2$ there exists $jin[1,pi/2epsilon]$ with $(j-1)tletheta<jt$. And (draw a picture of all this) that implies $|1-z^j|>alpha$.
– David C. Ullrich
Jan 3 at 22:26
|
show 1 more comment
Your Answer
StackExchange.ifUsing("editor", function () {
return StackExchange.using("mathjaxEditing", function () {
StackExchange.MarkdownEditor.creationCallbacks.add(function (editor, postfix) {
StackExchange.mathjaxEditing.prepareWmdForMathJax(editor, postfix, [["$", "$"], ["\\(","\\)"]]);
});
});
}, "mathjax-editing");
StackExchange.ready(function() {
var channelOptions = {
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "69"
};
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);
StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function() {
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled) {
StackExchange.using("snippets", function() {
createEditor();
});
}
else {
createEditor();
}
});
function createEditor() {
StackExchange.prepareEditor({
heartbeatType: 'answer',
autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
convertImagesToLinks: true,
noModals: true,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: 10,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
imageUploader: {
brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
allowUrls: true
},
noCode: true, onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
});
}
});
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmath.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f2622521%2fpontryagin-dual-group-inherits-local-compactness%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
This is a little silly, since there must be a proof out there in books.
The local compactness of $hat G$ is going to come from equicontinuity.
Say $K$ is a compact neighborhood of the identity in $G$, $0<alpha<1$, and $E$ is the set of all $chiinhat G$ such that $|1-chi|<alpha$ on $K$. Then $E$ is equicontinuous at the origin: Given $epsilon>0$, there exists $n$ such that if $zinBbb T$ and $epsilonle|1-z|<alpha$ then $|1-z^j|>alpha$ for at least one integer $j$ with $1le jle n$ (the fact that $alpha<1$ can't be omitted there.)
Edit: When I wrote this I was taking that last sentence as clear.. In answer to a comment, here's a formal proof. Note first that $|1-e^{is}|$ is a strictly increasing function of $s$, for $sin[0,pi]$. Now wlog $z$ has positive imaginary part. Hence there exists $tin (0,pi/2]$ with $z=e^{it}$. So $tge|1-e^{it}|>epsilon$. Choose $thetain(0,pi)$ with $|1-e^{itheta}|=alpha$. Since $t>epsilon$ there exists $j$ with $1le jle theta/epsilon+1<pi/(2epsilon)+1$ such that $(j-1)tle theta<jt$.
Hence $jt=(j-1)t+tle theta+pi/2lepi$. Since $theta<jtlepi$ the mmontonicity mentioned above shows that $|1-z^j|>|1-e^{itheta}|=alpha$.
Now choose a neighborhood of the origin $U$ such that $U+U+Udots +Usubset K$. Then if $chiin E$ the fact that $chi$ is multiplicative shows that $|1-chi|<epsilon$ on $U$.
So $E$ is equicontinuous at the origin, and hence uniformly equicontinuous at every point. Now a suitable version of Arzela-Ascoli(???) must show that $E$ is precompact in the compact-open topology.
Surely that's all there is to it.
Edit: Yes, that's all there is to it.
Details: Say a modulus of continuity on $G$ is a function $omega:(0,infty)tomathcal P(G)$ such that (i) $omega(epsilon)$ is a neighborhood of the identity for every $epsilon>0$ and $(ii)$ $-omega(epsilon)=omega(epsilon)$. (Note: (ii) is just for convenience; it's no real restriction, since if $omega$ satisfies (i) and $omega'(epsilon)=omega(epsilon)cap(-omega(epsilon))$ then $omega'$ satisfies (i) and (ii).)
Let $hat G_omega$ be the set of $chiinhat G$ such that $x-yinomega(epsilon)$ implies $|chi(x)-chi(y)|leepsilon$.
We're trying to show that $E$ is precompact. Above we've shown that there is a modulus of continuity $omega$ such that if $chiin E$ and $xinomega(epsilon)$ then $|1-chi(x)|<epsilon$. It follows that $chiinhat G_omega$: If $x-yinomega(epsilon)$ then $$|chi(x)-chi(y)|=|chi(x)(1-chi(y-x)|=|1-chi(y-x)|<epsilon.$$
So $Esubsethat G_omega$, and hence we need only show this:
If $omega$ is a modulus of continuity on $G$ then $hat G_omega$ is compact (in the compact-open topology).
This is just Arzela-Ascoli. I don't recall seeing a version that applies directly, so we just prove it.
The proof is clearest in terms of nets. We need to show that every net has a convergent subnet. In a word, Tychonoff gies pointwise convergence and then equicontinuity shows that pointwise convegence implies uniform convergence on compact sets.
Say $(chi_alpha)$ is a net in $hat G_omega$. Regarding $hat G_omega$ as a subset of the product space $Bbb T^G$, Tychonoff shows that there is a pointwise convergent subnet. So we need only show this:
If $omega $ is a modulus of continuity on $G$ and $(chi_alpha)$ is a net in $hat G_omega$ such that $chi_alpha(x)tochi(x)$ for every $xin G$ then $chiin hat G_omega$ and $chi_alphatochi$ uniformly on compact sets.
Proof: The pointwise convergence makes it clear that $chiinhat G_omega$. Suppose $Ksubset G$ is compact and $epsilon>0$. Let $U=omega(epsilon)$ and choose $x_1,dots,x_nin K$ with $$Ksubsetbigcup_{j=1}^n(x_j+U).$$
Now there exists $beta$ such that if $alpha>beta$ then $$|chi_alpha(x_j)-chi(x_j)|<epsilonquad(j=1,2,dots,n).$$
Suppose $alpha>beta$ and $xin K$. Choose $j$ so $xin x_j+U$. Then
$$|chi_alpha(x)-chi(x)|le|chi_alpha(x)-chi_alpha(x_j)|+|chi_alpha(x_j)-chi(x_j)|+|chi(x_j)-chi(x)|<3epsilon.$$
Ok, so I will change my question into a positive one.
– Andrea Marino
Jan 26 '18 at 19:57
@AndreaMarino Wake up - the proof you ordered is ready...
– David C. Ullrich
Jan 28 '18 at 16:12
For whoever asked that deleted question: Say $z=e^{it}$, $0<t<pi/2$. Choose $thetain(0,pi/2)$ with $|1-e^{itheta}|=alpha$. Let $j$ be the smallest positive integer with $jt>theta$.
– David C. Ullrich
Jan 3 at 16:18
@DavidC.Ullrich: That was probably me, and I was asking whether the statement "Given $epsilon>0$, there exists $n$ such that if [...]" is obvious. How do you construct this $n$ which must be independent of all $z$?
– Alex M.
Jan 3 at 22:12
@AlexM. I gave an outline in my last comment. II should have said wlog $z$ has positive imaginary part. More details: Knowing that $|1-z|>epsilon$ shows that $t>epsilon$. Since $theta<pi/2$ there exists $jin[1,pi/2epsilon]$ with $(j-1)tletheta<jt$. And (draw a picture of all this) that implies $|1-z^j|>alpha$.
– David C. Ullrich
Jan 3 at 22:26
|
show 1 more comment
This is a little silly, since there must be a proof out there in books.
The local compactness of $hat G$ is going to come from equicontinuity.
Say $K$ is a compact neighborhood of the identity in $G$, $0<alpha<1$, and $E$ is the set of all $chiinhat G$ such that $|1-chi|<alpha$ on $K$. Then $E$ is equicontinuous at the origin: Given $epsilon>0$, there exists $n$ such that if $zinBbb T$ and $epsilonle|1-z|<alpha$ then $|1-z^j|>alpha$ for at least one integer $j$ with $1le jle n$ (the fact that $alpha<1$ can't be omitted there.)
Edit: When I wrote this I was taking that last sentence as clear.. In answer to a comment, here's a formal proof. Note first that $|1-e^{is}|$ is a strictly increasing function of $s$, for $sin[0,pi]$. Now wlog $z$ has positive imaginary part. Hence there exists $tin (0,pi/2]$ with $z=e^{it}$. So $tge|1-e^{it}|>epsilon$. Choose $thetain(0,pi)$ with $|1-e^{itheta}|=alpha$. Since $t>epsilon$ there exists $j$ with $1le jle theta/epsilon+1<pi/(2epsilon)+1$ such that $(j-1)tle theta<jt$.
Hence $jt=(j-1)t+tle theta+pi/2lepi$. Since $theta<jtlepi$ the mmontonicity mentioned above shows that $|1-z^j|>|1-e^{itheta}|=alpha$.
Now choose a neighborhood of the origin $U$ such that $U+U+Udots +Usubset K$. Then if $chiin E$ the fact that $chi$ is multiplicative shows that $|1-chi|<epsilon$ on $U$.
So $E$ is equicontinuous at the origin, and hence uniformly equicontinuous at every point. Now a suitable version of Arzela-Ascoli(???) must show that $E$ is precompact in the compact-open topology.
Surely that's all there is to it.
Edit: Yes, that's all there is to it.
Details: Say a modulus of continuity on $G$ is a function $omega:(0,infty)tomathcal P(G)$ such that (i) $omega(epsilon)$ is a neighborhood of the identity for every $epsilon>0$ and $(ii)$ $-omega(epsilon)=omega(epsilon)$. (Note: (ii) is just for convenience; it's no real restriction, since if $omega$ satisfies (i) and $omega'(epsilon)=omega(epsilon)cap(-omega(epsilon))$ then $omega'$ satisfies (i) and (ii).)
Let $hat G_omega$ be the set of $chiinhat G$ such that $x-yinomega(epsilon)$ implies $|chi(x)-chi(y)|leepsilon$.
We're trying to show that $E$ is precompact. Above we've shown that there is a modulus of continuity $omega$ such that if $chiin E$ and $xinomega(epsilon)$ then $|1-chi(x)|<epsilon$. It follows that $chiinhat G_omega$: If $x-yinomega(epsilon)$ then $$|chi(x)-chi(y)|=|chi(x)(1-chi(y-x)|=|1-chi(y-x)|<epsilon.$$
So $Esubsethat G_omega$, and hence we need only show this:
If $omega$ is a modulus of continuity on $G$ then $hat G_omega$ is compact (in the compact-open topology).
This is just Arzela-Ascoli. I don't recall seeing a version that applies directly, so we just prove it.
The proof is clearest in terms of nets. We need to show that every net has a convergent subnet. In a word, Tychonoff gies pointwise convergence and then equicontinuity shows that pointwise convegence implies uniform convergence on compact sets.
Say $(chi_alpha)$ is a net in $hat G_omega$. Regarding $hat G_omega$ as a subset of the product space $Bbb T^G$, Tychonoff shows that there is a pointwise convergent subnet. So we need only show this:
If $omega $ is a modulus of continuity on $G$ and $(chi_alpha)$ is a net in $hat G_omega$ such that $chi_alpha(x)tochi(x)$ for every $xin G$ then $chiin hat G_omega$ and $chi_alphatochi$ uniformly on compact sets.
Proof: The pointwise convergence makes it clear that $chiinhat G_omega$. Suppose $Ksubset G$ is compact and $epsilon>0$. Let $U=omega(epsilon)$ and choose $x_1,dots,x_nin K$ with $$Ksubsetbigcup_{j=1}^n(x_j+U).$$
Now there exists $beta$ such that if $alpha>beta$ then $$|chi_alpha(x_j)-chi(x_j)|<epsilonquad(j=1,2,dots,n).$$
Suppose $alpha>beta$ and $xin K$. Choose $j$ so $xin x_j+U$. Then
$$|chi_alpha(x)-chi(x)|le|chi_alpha(x)-chi_alpha(x_j)|+|chi_alpha(x_j)-chi(x_j)|+|chi(x_j)-chi(x)|<3epsilon.$$
Ok, so I will change my question into a positive one.
– Andrea Marino
Jan 26 '18 at 19:57
@AndreaMarino Wake up - the proof you ordered is ready...
– David C. Ullrich
Jan 28 '18 at 16:12
For whoever asked that deleted question: Say $z=e^{it}$, $0<t<pi/2$. Choose $thetain(0,pi/2)$ with $|1-e^{itheta}|=alpha$. Let $j$ be the smallest positive integer with $jt>theta$.
– David C. Ullrich
Jan 3 at 16:18
@DavidC.Ullrich: That was probably me, and I was asking whether the statement "Given $epsilon>0$, there exists $n$ such that if [...]" is obvious. How do you construct this $n$ which must be independent of all $z$?
– Alex M.
Jan 3 at 22:12
@AlexM. I gave an outline in my last comment. II should have said wlog $z$ has positive imaginary part. More details: Knowing that $|1-z|>epsilon$ shows that $t>epsilon$. Since $theta<pi/2$ there exists $jin[1,pi/2epsilon]$ with $(j-1)tletheta<jt$. And (draw a picture of all this) that implies $|1-z^j|>alpha$.
– David C. Ullrich
Jan 3 at 22:26
|
show 1 more comment
This is a little silly, since there must be a proof out there in books.
The local compactness of $hat G$ is going to come from equicontinuity.
Say $K$ is a compact neighborhood of the identity in $G$, $0<alpha<1$, and $E$ is the set of all $chiinhat G$ such that $|1-chi|<alpha$ on $K$. Then $E$ is equicontinuous at the origin: Given $epsilon>0$, there exists $n$ such that if $zinBbb T$ and $epsilonle|1-z|<alpha$ then $|1-z^j|>alpha$ for at least one integer $j$ with $1le jle n$ (the fact that $alpha<1$ can't be omitted there.)
Edit: When I wrote this I was taking that last sentence as clear.. In answer to a comment, here's a formal proof. Note first that $|1-e^{is}|$ is a strictly increasing function of $s$, for $sin[0,pi]$. Now wlog $z$ has positive imaginary part. Hence there exists $tin (0,pi/2]$ with $z=e^{it}$. So $tge|1-e^{it}|>epsilon$. Choose $thetain(0,pi)$ with $|1-e^{itheta}|=alpha$. Since $t>epsilon$ there exists $j$ with $1le jle theta/epsilon+1<pi/(2epsilon)+1$ such that $(j-1)tle theta<jt$.
Hence $jt=(j-1)t+tle theta+pi/2lepi$. Since $theta<jtlepi$ the mmontonicity mentioned above shows that $|1-z^j|>|1-e^{itheta}|=alpha$.
Now choose a neighborhood of the origin $U$ such that $U+U+Udots +Usubset K$. Then if $chiin E$ the fact that $chi$ is multiplicative shows that $|1-chi|<epsilon$ on $U$.
So $E$ is equicontinuous at the origin, and hence uniformly equicontinuous at every point. Now a suitable version of Arzela-Ascoli(???) must show that $E$ is precompact in the compact-open topology.
Surely that's all there is to it.
Edit: Yes, that's all there is to it.
Details: Say a modulus of continuity on $G$ is a function $omega:(0,infty)tomathcal P(G)$ such that (i) $omega(epsilon)$ is a neighborhood of the identity for every $epsilon>0$ and $(ii)$ $-omega(epsilon)=omega(epsilon)$. (Note: (ii) is just for convenience; it's no real restriction, since if $omega$ satisfies (i) and $omega'(epsilon)=omega(epsilon)cap(-omega(epsilon))$ then $omega'$ satisfies (i) and (ii).)
Let $hat G_omega$ be the set of $chiinhat G$ such that $x-yinomega(epsilon)$ implies $|chi(x)-chi(y)|leepsilon$.
We're trying to show that $E$ is precompact. Above we've shown that there is a modulus of continuity $omega$ such that if $chiin E$ and $xinomega(epsilon)$ then $|1-chi(x)|<epsilon$. It follows that $chiinhat G_omega$: If $x-yinomega(epsilon)$ then $$|chi(x)-chi(y)|=|chi(x)(1-chi(y-x)|=|1-chi(y-x)|<epsilon.$$
So $Esubsethat G_omega$, and hence we need only show this:
If $omega$ is a modulus of continuity on $G$ then $hat G_omega$ is compact (in the compact-open topology).
This is just Arzela-Ascoli. I don't recall seeing a version that applies directly, so we just prove it.
The proof is clearest in terms of nets. We need to show that every net has a convergent subnet. In a word, Tychonoff gies pointwise convergence and then equicontinuity shows that pointwise convegence implies uniform convergence on compact sets.
Say $(chi_alpha)$ is a net in $hat G_omega$. Regarding $hat G_omega$ as a subset of the product space $Bbb T^G$, Tychonoff shows that there is a pointwise convergent subnet. So we need only show this:
If $omega $ is a modulus of continuity on $G$ and $(chi_alpha)$ is a net in $hat G_omega$ such that $chi_alpha(x)tochi(x)$ for every $xin G$ then $chiin hat G_omega$ and $chi_alphatochi$ uniformly on compact sets.
Proof: The pointwise convergence makes it clear that $chiinhat G_omega$. Suppose $Ksubset G$ is compact and $epsilon>0$. Let $U=omega(epsilon)$ and choose $x_1,dots,x_nin K$ with $$Ksubsetbigcup_{j=1}^n(x_j+U).$$
Now there exists $beta$ such that if $alpha>beta$ then $$|chi_alpha(x_j)-chi(x_j)|<epsilonquad(j=1,2,dots,n).$$
Suppose $alpha>beta$ and $xin K$. Choose $j$ so $xin x_j+U$. Then
$$|chi_alpha(x)-chi(x)|le|chi_alpha(x)-chi_alpha(x_j)|+|chi_alpha(x_j)-chi(x_j)|+|chi(x_j)-chi(x)|<3epsilon.$$
This is a little silly, since there must be a proof out there in books.
The local compactness of $hat G$ is going to come from equicontinuity.
Say $K$ is a compact neighborhood of the identity in $G$, $0<alpha<1$, and $E$ is the set of all $chiinhat G$ such that $|1-chi|<alpha$ on $K$. Then $E$ is equicontinuous at the origin: Given $epsilon>0$, there exists $n$ such that if $zinBbb T$ and $epsilonle|1-z|<alpha$ then $|1-z^j|>alpha$ for at least one integer $j$ with $1le jle n$ (the fact that $alpha<1$ can't be omitted there.)
Edit: When I wrote this I was taking that last sentence as clear.. In answer to a comment, here's a formal proof. Note first that $|1-e^{is}|$ is a strictly increasing function of $s$, for $sin[0,pi]$. Now wlog $z$ has positive imaginary part. Hence there exists $tin (0,pi/2]$ with $z=e^{it}$. So $tge|1-e^{it}|>epsilon$. Choose $thetain(0,pi)$ with $|1-e^{itheta}|=alpha$. Since $t>epsilon$ there exists $j$ with $1le jle theta/epsilon+1<pi/(2epsilon)+1$ such that $(j-1)tle theta<jt$.
Hence $jt=(j-1)t+tle theta+pi/2lepi$. Since $theta<jtlepi$ the mmontonicity mentioned above shows that $|1-z^j|>|1-e^{itheta}|=alpha$.
Now choose a neighborhood of the origin $U$ such that $U+U+Udots +Usubset K$. Then if $chiin E$ the fact that $chi$ is multiplicative shows that $|1-chi|<epsilon$ on $U$.
So $E$ is equicontinuous at the origin, and hence uniformly equicontinuous at every point. Now a suitable version of Arzela-Ascoli(???) must show that $E$ is precompact in the compact-open topology.
Surely that's all there is to it.
Edit: Yes, that's all there is to it.
Details: Say a modulus of continuity on $G$ is a function $omega:(0,infty)tomathcal P(G)$ such that (i) $omega(epsilon)$ is a neighborhood of the identity for every $epsilon>0$ and $(ii)$ $-omega(epsilon)=omega(epsilon)$. (Note: (ii) is just for convenience; it's no real restriction, since if $omega$ satisfies (i) and $omega'(epsilon)=omega(epsilon)cap(-omega(epsilon))$ then $omega'$ satisfies (i) and (ii).)
Let $hat G_omega$ be the set of $chiinhat G$ such that $x-yinomega(epsilon)$ implies $|chi(x)-chi(y)|leepsilon$.
We're trying to show that $E$ is precompact. Above we've shown that there is a modulus of continuity $omega$ such that if $chiin E$ and $xinomega(epsilon)$ then $|1-chi(x)|<epsilon$. It follows that $chiinhat G_omega$: If $x-yinomega(epsilon)$ then $$|chi(x)-chi(y)|=|chi(x)(1-chi(y-x)|=|1-chi(y-x)|<epsilon.$$
So $Esubsethat G_omega$, and hence we need only show this:
If $omega$ is a modulus of continuity on $G$ then $hat G_omega$ is compact (in the compact-open topology).
This is just Arzela-Ascoli. I don't recall seeing a version that applies directly, so we just prove it.
The proof is clearest in terms of nets. We need to show that every net has a convergent subnet. In a word, Tychonoff gies pointwise convergence and then equicontinuity shows that pointwise convegence implies uniform convergence on compact sets.
Say $(chi_alpha)$ is a net in $hat G_omega$. Regarding $hat G_omega$ as a subset of the product space $Bbb T^G$, Tychonoff shows that there is a pointwise convergent subnet. So we need only show this:
If $omega $ is a modulus of continuity on $G$ and $(chi_alpha)$ is a net in $hat G_omega$ such that $chi_alpha(x)tochi(x)$ for every $xin G$ then $chiin hat G_omega$ and $chi_alphatochi$ uniformly on compact sets.
Proof: The pointwise convergence makes it clear that $chiinhat G_omega$. Suppose $Ksubset G$ is compact and $epsilon>0$. Let $U=omega(epsilon)$ and choose $x_1,dots,x_nin K$ with $$Ksubsetbigcup_{j=1}^n(x_j+U).$$
Now there exists $beta$ such that if $alpha>beta$ then $$|chi_alpha(x_j)-chi(x_j)|<epsilonquad(j=1,2,dots,n).$$
Suppose $alpha>beta$ and $xin K$. Choose $j$ so $xin x_j+U$. Then
$$|chi_alpha(x)-chi(x)|le|chi_alpha(x)-chi_alpha(x_j)|+|chi_alpha(x_j)-chi(x_j)|+|chi(x_j)-chi(x)|<3epsilon.$$
edited Jan 4 at 14:44
answered Jan 26 '18 at 19:56
David C. UllrichDavid C. Ullrich
59.2k43892
59.2k43892
Ok, so I will change my question into a positive one.
– Andrea Marino
Jan 26 '18 at 19:57
@AndreaMarino Wake up - the proof you ordered is ready...
– David C. Ullrich
Jan 28 '18 at 16:12
For whoever asked that deleted question: Say $z=e^{it}$, $0<t<pi/2$. Choose $thetain(0,pi/2)$ with $|1-e^{itheta}|=alpha$. Let $j$ be the smallest positive integer with $jt>theta$.
– David C. Ullrich
Jan 3 at 16:18
@DavidC.Ullrich: That was probably me, and I was asking whether the statement "Given $epsilon>0$, there exists $n$ such that if [...]" is obvious. How do you construct this $n$ which must be independent of all $z$?
– Alex M.
Jan 3 at 22:12
@AlexM. I gave an outline in my last comment. II should have said wlog $z$ has positive imaginary part. More details: Knowing that $|1-z|>epsilon$ shows that $t>epsilon$. Since $theta<pi/2$ there exists $jin[1,pi/2epsilon]$ with $(j-1)tletheta<jt$. And (draw a picture of all this) that implies $|1-z^j|>alpha$.
– David C. Ullrich
Jan 3 at 22:26
|
show 1 more comment
Ok, so I will change my question into a positive one.
– Andrea Marino
Jan 26 '18 at 19:57
@AndreaMarino Wake up - the proof you ordered is ready...
– David C. Ullrich
Jan 28 '18 at 16:12
For whoever asked that deleted question: Say $z=e^{it}$, $0<t<pi/2$. Choose $thetain(0,pi/2)$ with $|1-e^{itheta}|=alpha$. Let $j$ be the smallest positive integer with $jt>theta$.
– David C. Ullrich
Jan 3 at 16:18
@DavidC.Ullrich: That was probably me, and I was asking whether the statement "Given $epsilon>0$, there exists $n$ such that if [...]" is obvious. How do you construct this $n$ which must be independent of all $z$?
– Alex M.
Jan 3 at 22:12
@AlexM. I gave an outline in my last comment. II should have said wlog $z$ has positive imaginary part. More details: Knowing that $|1-z|>epsilon$ shows that $t>epsilon$. Since $theta<pi/2$ there exists $jin[1,pi/2epsilon]$ with $(j-1)tletheta<jt$. And (draw a picture of all this) that implies $|1-z^j|>alpha$.
– David C. Ullrich
Jan 3 at 22:26
Ok, so I will change my question into a positive one.
– Andrea Marino
Jan 26 '18 at 19:57
Ok, so I will change my question into a positive one.
– Andrea Marino
Jan 26 '18 at 19:57
@AndreaMarino Wake up - the proof you ordered is ready...
– David C. Ullrich
Jan 28 '18 at 16:12
@AndreaMarino Wake up - the proof you ordered is ready...
– David C. Ullrich
Jan 28 '18 at 16:12
For whoever asked that deleted question: Say $z=e^{it}$, $0<t<pi/2$. Choose $thetain(0,pi/2)$ with $|1-e^{itheta}|=alpha$. Let $j$ be the smallest positive integer with $jt>theta$.
– David C. Ullrich
Jan 3 at 16:18
For whoever asked that deleted question: Say $z=e^{it}$, $0<t<pi/2$. Choose $thetain(0,pi/2)$ with $|1-e^{itheta}|=alpha$. Let $j$ be the smallest positive integer with $jt>theta$.
– David C. Ullrich
Jan 3 at 16:18
@DavidC.Ullrich: That was probably me, and I was asking whether the statement "Given $epsilon>0$, there exists $n$ such that if [...]" is obvious. How do you construct this $n$ which must be independent of all $z$?
– Alex M.
Jan 3 at 22:12
@DavidC.Ullrich: That was probably me, and I was asking whether the statement "Given $epsilon>0$, there exists $n$ such that if [...]" is obvious. How do you construct this $n$ which must be independent of all $z$?
– Alex M.
Jan 3 at 22:12
@AlexM. I gave an outline in my last comment. II should have said wlog $z$ has positive imaginary part. More details: Knowing that $|1-z|>epsilon$ shows that $t>epsilon$. Since $theta<pi/2$ there exists $jin[1,pi/2epsilon]$ with $(j-1)tletheta<jt$. And (draw a picture of all this) that implies $|1-z^j|>alpha$.
– David C. Ullrich
Jan 3 at 22:26
@AlexM. I gave an outline in my last comment. II should have said wlog $z$ has positive imaginary part. More details: Knowing that $|1-z|>epsilon$ shows that $t>epsilon$. Since $theta<pi/2$ there exists $jin[1,pi/2epsilon]$ with $(j-1)tletheta<jt$. And (draw a picture of all this) that implies $|1-z^j|>alpha$.
– David C. Ullrich
Jan 3 at 22:26
|
show 1 more comment
Thanks for contributing an answer to Mathematics Stack Exchange!
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
Use MathJax to format equations. MathJax reference.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Some of your past answers have not been well-received, and you're in danger of being blocked from answering.
Please pay close attention to the following guidance:
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmath.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f2622521%2fpontryagin-dual-group-inherits-local-compactness%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown