Can one use an automatic sugar dispenser on shabbat?












6














An automatic sugar dispenser is a device that mechanically releases a specific amount of sugar (e.g. half a teaspoon) at the press of a button.



No electricity is involved, nor would there seem to be an issue of grinding.



However, measuring on shabbat is (in principle) forbidden.



Would using this dispenser to obtain a pre-specified amount of sugar for one's hot drink be considered to fall under 'measuring' and thus forbidden on shabbat?










share|improve this question
























  • Related ומדבריהם למדנו שפוקקין ומודדין וקושרין בשבת
    – Dr. Shmuel
    8 hours ago










  • @Dr.Shmuel Isn’t that only for a דבר מצוה?
    – Joel K
    6 hours ago
















6














An automatic sugar dispenser is a device that mechanically releases a specific amount of sugar (e.g. half a teaspoon) at the press of a button.



No electricity is involved, nor would there seem to be an issue of grinding.



However, measuring on shabbat is (in principle) forbidden.



Would using this dispenser to obtain a pre-specified amount of sugar for one's hot drink be considered to fall under 'measuring' and thus forbidden on shabbat?










share|improve this question
























  • Related ומדבריהם למדנו שפוקקין ומודדין וקושרין בשבת
    – Dr. Shmuel
    8 hours ago










  • @Dr.Shmuel Isn’t that only for a דבר מצוה?
    – Joel K
    6 hours ago














6












6








6







An automatic sugar dispenser is a device that mechanically releases a specific amount of sugar (e.g. half a teaspoon) at the press of a button.



No electricity is involved, nor would there seem to be an issue of grinding.



However, measuring on shabbat is (in principle) forbidden.



Would using this dispenser to obtain a pre-specified amount of sugar for one's hot drink be considered to fall under 'measuring' and thus forbidden on shabbat?










share|improve this question















An automatic sugar dispenser is a device that mechanically releases a specific amount of sugar (e.g. half a teaspoon) at the press of a button.



No electricity is involved, nor would there seem to be an issue of grinding.



However, measuring on shabbat is (in principle) forbidden.



Would using this dispenser to obtain a pre-specified amount of sugar for one's hot drink be considered to fall under 'measuring' and thus forbidden on shabbat?







halacha shabbat






share|improve this question















share|improve this question













share|improve this question




share|improve this question








edited yesterday







Joel K

















asked yesterday









Joel KJoel K

11.7k22478




11.7k22478












  • Related ומדבריהם למדנו שפוקקין ומודדין וקושרין בשבת
    – Dr. Shmuel
    8 hours ago










  • @Dr.Shmuel Isn’t that only for a דבר מצוה?
    – Joel K
    6 hours ago


















  • Related ומדבריהם למדנו שפוקקין ומודדין וקושרין בשבת
    – Dr. Shmuel
    8 hours ago










  • @Dr.Shmuel Isn’t that only for a דבר מצוה?
    – Joel K
    6 hours ago
















Related ומדבריהם למדנו שפוקקין ומודדין וקושרין בשבת
– Dr. Shmuel
8 hours ago




Related ומדבריהם למדנו שפוקקין ומודדין וקושרין בשבת
– Dr. Shmuel
8 hours ago












@Dr.Shmuel Isn’t that only for a דבר מצוה?
– Joel K
6 hours ago




@Dr.Shmuel Isn’t that only for a דבר מצוה?
– Joel K
6 hours ago










1 Answer
1






active

oldest

votes


















10














According to the Shulchan Oruch quoted in the question, measuring when done for another person looks like Mekach uMemkar (buying and selling) since that person looks like a "buyer" and if using accurate measuring utensils onlookers will think there is a transaction (thus permitting such an action on Shabbos) and might come to make their own transactions and inadvertently write down the amount of money owed by the buyer.



See Mishna Brura OC 323,1 3 who says anything that clearly does not look like buying and selling between 2 people is permitted even in a measuring utensil, for example pouring for a guest, and how much more so pouring for oneself to eat!




שאין זה דרך מקח וממכר וגם לא מחזי כעובדין דחול שאף המשקה את חבירו בדרך מתנה דרכו ג"כ לפעמים להשקות בכלי המיוחד למדה:‏




So using a mechanical sugar dispenser for direct consumption for oneself or a guest is permitted on Shabbos.






share|improve this answer































    1 Answer
    1






    active

    oldest

    votes








    1 Answer
    1






    active

    oldest

    votes









    active

    oldest

    votes






    active

    oldest

    votes









    10














    According to the Shulchan Oruch quoted in the question, measuring when done for another person looks like Mekach uMemkar (buying and selling) since that person looks like a "buyer" and if using accurate measuring utensils onlookers will think there is a transaction (thus permitting such an action on Shabbos) and might come to make their own transactions and inadvertently write down the amount of money owed by the buyer.



    See Mishna Brura OC 323,1 3 who says anything that clearly does not look like buying and selling between 2 people is permitted even in a measuring utensil, for example pouring for a guest, and how much more so pouring for oneself to eat!




    שאין זה דרך מקח וממכר וגם לא מחזי כעובדין דחול שאף המשקה את חבירו בדרך מתנה דרכו ג"כ לפעמים להשקות בכלי המיוחד למדה:‏




    So using a mechanical sugar dispenser for direct consumption for oneself or a guest is permitted on Shabbos.






    share|improve this answer




























      10














      According to the Shulchan Oruch quoted in the question, measuring when done for another person looks like Mekach uMemkar (buying and selling) since that person looks like a "buyer" and if using accurate measuring utensils onlookers will think there is a transaction (thus permitting such an action on Shabbos) and might come to make their own transactions and inadvertently write down the amount of money owed by the buyer.



      See Mishna Brura OC 323,1 3 who says anything that clearly does not look like buying and selling between 2 people is permitted even in a measuring utensil, for example pouring for a guest, and how much more so pouring for oneself to eat!




      שאין זה דרך מקח וממכר וגם לא מחזי כעובדין דחול שאף המשקה את חבירו בדרך מתנה דרכו ג"כ לפעמים להשקות בכלי המיוחד למדה:‏




      So using a mechanical sugar dispenser for direct consumption for oneself or a guest is permitted on Shabbos.






      share|improve this answer


























        10












        10








        10






        According to the Shulchan Oruch quoted in the question, measuring when done for another person looks like Mekach uMemkar (buying and selling) since that person looks like a "buyer" and if using accurate measuring utensils onlookers will think there is a transaction (thus permitting such an action on Shabbos) and might come to make their own transactions and inadvertently write down the amount of money owed by the buyer.



        See Mishna Brura OC 323,1 3 who says anything that clearly does not look like buying and selling between 2 people is permitted even in a measuring utensil, for example pouring for a guest, and how much more so pouring for oneself to eat!




        שאין זה דרך מקח וממכר וגם לא מחזי כעובדין דחול שאף המשקה את חבירו בדרך מתנה דרכו ג"כ לפעמים להשקות בכלי המיוחד למדה:‏




        So using a mechanical sugar dispenser for direct consumption for oneself or a guest is permitted on Shabbos.






        share|improve this answer














        According to the Shulchan Oruch quoted in the question, measuring when done for another person looks like Mekach uMemkar (buying and selling) since that person looks like a "buyer" and if using accurate measuring utensils onlookers will think there is a transaction (thus permitting such an action on Shabbos) and might come to make their own transactions and inadvertently write down the amount of money owed by the buyer.



        See Mishna Brura OC 323,1 3 who says anything that clearly does not look like buying and selling between 2 people is permitted even in a measuring utensil, for example pouring for a guest, and how much more so pouring for oneself to eat!




        שאין זה דרך מקח וממכר וגם לא מחזי כעובדין דחול שאף המשקה את חבירו בדרך מתנה דרכו ג"כ לפעמים להשקות בכלי המיוחד למדה:‏




        So using a mechanical sugar dispenser for direct consumption for oneself or a guest is permitted on Shabbos.







        share|improve this answer














        share|improve this answer



        share|improve this answer








        edited 17 hours ago









        Joel K

        11.7k22478




        11.7k22478










        answered yesterday









        user15464user15464

        3,664844




        3,664844















            Popular posts from this blog

            An IMO inspired problem

            Management

            Has there ever been an instance of an active nuclear power plant within or near a war zone?